لطفا منتظر باشید ...
بنام خداوند بخشنده مهربان
خلاصه مناظره فرضى در خصوص افتراقات شيعه و سنّى
موضوعات:
1- اهل بيت شناسى
2- مهدويت
تهيه كننده:
محسن عاليخانى
(زبان: انگليسى)
مهر ماه 82
In the name of God
the commpassionate, the merciful
Summary of an imaginary dialogue about:
1. prophets houschold
2. re- appearance of Mahdi
by:
MOHSEN ALI KHANI
1. Peophets houschold
- Hello
- Hello, My brother.
- I have some questions about prophets houschold, according to shitts points of view.
- OK, go on please.
- Who are named as prophets houschold
- Definitely, shitte believes that Imam Ali, Fatimah, daughter of prophet, and two sons of her, Hassan and Hossein are considered as "prophets houschold"
- Would you please give your idea about sayings, claiming that wives and relatives of prophet should be considered as his house hold too
- A good question. In response, I should say that there are both historical witnesses (traditions) and logical reasons:
In "Sahih of Moslem, vol. 4, page 1883 - NO. 2424" Ayeshah narrates: "Wher prophet receved the verse of "TATHIR" (about household of him), he gathered Ali, Fatimah, Hassan and Hossein and called them as his own household. omsalamah who was present requested to join them, but prophet disagreed..."
About relatives, its apparant that some of them either denied Islam or struggled against it (suchas Abu lahab) or didnt behave fairly. so, as sinlessness is a neccesity for prophets household, its not logic to extend the concept of "household" to "relatives".
- Would you pleas explain more about TATHIR verse
the trans lation of verse:
"Ohousehold of prophet, Surely, God wants you be out of all sins and impurities, and the you will be completely infallible"
- there is another traditlon about household of prophet:
saglain ( two important things) trsdition [Sahih of Moslem - vol 4 - page 1803] :
prophet in a preach said: I leave a will and thats seglain (2 invaluable things), first, haly lcoran, that should be considered more, and second," My own household"
Also in another refrence [sonan of termezi] is mentioned: "...they wont separate each other all the time."
Would you lcindly explain asme specific aspects of prophets houssehold
- oh, yes,:
1. religous knowledge: they are the most snitable for interpretatian of Holy book
2. both " Holy kORAN" and "Prophets household" should be considered with each other.
- Would you speak about 12 (kalifs) Imams of shitts
- yes, referring to several refrence books of sonnis, there are many prophetic traditions mentinirg that 12 kalifs will make Islam high and significant.
Nat any other interpretation goes true with the tradition, except 12 Imams of shitts, whom all are from GHORALSH tribe and the last of them is still alive.
2. re- appearance of expected Mahdi
- please explain the main deffereces between sonni and shitt sects about "reappearance of mahdi"
- the differences between sonni and shitte points of view can be cathegorized to two category:
A- some sonni scholars have denled totally the matter of "re- appearance"
B- some others have raised dought alout tle man who will re-appear. theyve accepted the concept of re-appearance, but denied that the man appearing will be 12 Imam of shitts, who is living just now (who is alive)
